During Thursday’s explosive episode, the islanders had to decide whether to stay with their OG partners or discover new connections in the house of love.
While Cluadia, 28, didn’t pursue anyone in her absence, Casey, 26, got to know Cynthia, 26.
Host Maya Jama first asked Casey who he wanted to pair up with and viewers were shocked when he said he wanted to pair up with Claudia again.
When asked if he had stayed faithful during Casa, Casey shared that none of the connections came close to what he had with Claudia – which ultimately left Claudia in disbelief.
After Cynthia remembered the steamy moment the pair shared on the patio, she turned away in tears as her Casa co-stars comforted her.
Love Island is back for 2023
Say goodbye to your social life as Love Island is back for the Winter 2023 series.
Get the latest Love Island updates Metro.nl‘s special page.
Things also took a fiery turn when Claudia laughed at a comment she made to Casey, which led to Layla Al-Momani telling her “you shouldn’t be laughing.”
Fans immediately took to Twitter to share their frustrations, with one writing, “No, what Casey did to Cynthia. He has lost my respect. He led her on completely.’
Another added, “I really didn’t like the way Cynthia stood there crying, clearly upset and Casey and Claudia laughing? Nervous or not, that’s annoying and uncomfortable for her, so glad the casa girls were there.’
A 3rd particular person tweeted, “I knew Casey would not select Cynthia however the way in which he went about it and wasn’t upfront with each women is horrible. Claudia most likely thinks Casey did not do something deep, however we have all seen how gassed the man was over Cynthia. Claudia ought to positively apologize.’
“The best way Casey and Claudia laughed whereas Cynthia was upset actually pissed me off,” added one other.
Love Island returns tomorrow at 9pm on ITV2.
Do you may have a narrative?
You probably have a celeb story, video or photographs, please contact the Metro.co.uk leisure group by emailing celebtips@metro.co.uk, calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff web page. love to listen to from you.
MORE: Love Island spoiler sees Maya Jama return for explosive Casa Amor relink as Casey O’Gorman predicts ‘damaged hearts’
MORE: When Will Love Island’s Casa Amor Finish? Date of the notorious Stick or Twist episode revealed
